Were Hibernian Right To Sack Shaun Maloney? Have Things Improved At Hibs One Year On?

Were Hibernian Right To Sack Shaun Maloney? Have Things Improved At Hibs One Year On?

By Callum McFadden.

Shaun Maloney was appointed as Hibernian manager one year ago today.

His spell in charge of the Hibees lasted only four months without a pre-season, or the opportunity to recruit a core of players to enable him to form a team in his image.

The former Scotland international replaced Jack Ross who had managed Hibs for two and half seasons prior to his departure, and he was replaced at Hibs by former Bristol City and Sunderland manager Lee Johnson.

I interviewed Shaun about his time in charge at Hibs a few weeks ago and I was in no doubt that he has learned a lot from his time in charge of the club.

I also got the sense that he would have approached things differently given the nature of a serious injury to his main goalscorer in Kevin Nisbet and the departure of fellow talisman Martin Boyle.

Since speaking to Shaun, the one question I have been pondering more than most is whether Hibs were any better off before his arrival and whether they are any better since his departure.

Without a pre-season under his belt, it is difficult to fully understand what he would have looked to build at the club if given the opportunity to recruit players in his image.

However, I had a look at the statistics showing the last eight games of Jack Ross, Shaun Maloney and Lee Johnson to see if I could answer the aforementioned questions.

Statistics of the last 8 games of Jack Ross, Shaun Maloney and Lee Johnson at Hibernian

Jack Ross

Won 1, Drew 1 and Lost 6 = 4 points accumulated.

4 goals scored and 12 against =  a goal difference of -8.

During this period, Martin Boyle played 7 matches and Kevin Nisbet played 8 matches.

Crucially, Jack Ross had a full pre-season with Hibs prior to these games.

Shaun Maloney

Won 1, Drew 3 and Lost 4 = 7 points accumulated.

5 goals scored and 9 goals conceded = goal difference of -4.

Martin Boyle was not available to play in any of those 8 games and Kevin Nisbet played in 3 games before being injured after 25 minutes to an ACL injury.

In contrast to Jack Ross, Shaun Maloney did not have a pre-season at Hibs.

Lee Johnson

Won 1, Drew 0, Lost 7 = 3 points accumulated.

8 goals scored and 19 goals conceded = a goal difference of -11.

Martin Boyle was available for 5 matches and Kevin Nisbet for 1 match.

Lee Johnson had a full pre-season with Hibs prior to these games.

I found those statistics particularly intriguing. They highlighted what I thought at the time of Maloney’s departure after only a few months at Hibs, which is that he was working under difficult circumstances without key players and without a pre-season under his belt.

Surely, he merited more time to build a team in his image before a judgement was made on his future.

Patience can reap rewards as has been shown at Aberdeen, who sit in 3rd place under Jim Goodwin. In his first 15 games at Aberdeen, Goodwin accumulated 14 points — similar to that of Maloney who had 15 points after his first 15 games.

Rather than press the panic button, Aberdeen backed Goodwin to regroup and recruit in pre-season which he was able to do with the support of the hierarchy at the club including Director of Football, Steven Gunn.

Goodwin has also looked to integrate academy players into his thinking too such as Josh MacKenzie and Connor Barron, in addition to singing players from across the U.K. and Europe such as Bojan Miovski and Luis Lopes.

I guess we will never know what could have been achieved at Hibs by Maloney and his staff, as that time was never given, but it is hard to make a case that things have improved at the club since his departure.


  • comment-avatar
    Mark M 1 year ago

    Maloney was a stupid appointment. He is nothing more than a Martinez mini-me, and look at how Belgium underperformed under his useless management, especially at this World Cup. Maloney’s style of play was unwatchable – pass after meaningless pass in defence, and hardly any attempts at goal. It was so slow, and so easy for the opposition to play against. And as for his signings, jeez.

    Barely anyone wanted Johnson at Hibs either, so to imply Maloney should still be at the club because Johnson is on a worse run is silly. I would, however, give him the January window as he is at least making the right noises about clearing out the squad and signing better, proven players. The biggest problem is coming form above, though – bad appointments, bad club transfer policy, bad everything. The Gordons have to go.

  • comment-avatar
    Davie G 1 year ago

    Mark M is correct in everything he says.

    The fans would like the product on the pitch to be successful prior to anything else.

    Seems to be getting run more like a US NFL team rather than a well run Scottish club.

    Get people in that know the Scottish game inside out from recruitment right through to coaching and the players on the park and THEN we will reap the rewards.

    We are fumbling in the dark at the moment and sacking managers all the time is not the answer but get rid of players too that cost them their jobs , care not a jot how long they’ve been at the club.